CarGurus or Autotrader?
Where’s the best place to sell your car online? Here, we compare online marketplaces CarGurus and Autotrader.
* All data below is accurate as of 01/02/23
Who is CarGurus?
CarGurus is a US-based business that was founded in 2006 by Langley Steinert, co-founder of TripAdvisor, as an automotive blog for consumers to review cars or ask questions. It now runs as an advertising platform for used and approved used cars. CarGurus started expanding internationally in 2014 and launched in the UK in December 2016.
How is CarGurus different to Autotrader?
CarGurus offers more than 90 car brands including Audi, Ford, Mercedes-Benz, Vauxhall and Volkswagen. Autotrader have over 100 car brands for you to choose from.
Autotrader
Autotrader lets you buy or sell used, approved-used and brand-new cars, along with bikes, motorhomes, caravans, trucks, plant and farm machinery. There are various ways to sell your car to suit your best needs – you can advertise your car on Autotrader or sell your car instantly through an instant offer if you’re looking sell your car straight-away.
CarGurus
CarGurus provides a variety of used and approved-used to choose from. With CarGurus, you can only sell your car to them for the price they send you through their partner company The Car Buying Group.
Finding the best deal
CarGurus ranks their search results by “best deal” sorted by an algorithm, which is based on CarGurus’ own instant market value alongside dealership ratings submitted by site users.
On Autotrader, you can choose which criteria matter to you most by selecting from a range of filters available.
Filter your search according to your needs
You can filter and refine your search on Autotrader by choosing the criteria that best suit your needs. Search by total price or monthly price or over a dozen further categories available, including gearbox, fuel type and car colour. You can also filter the distance of the dealerships or the method of car deliveries.
Find the best priced deals
Autotrader ads also feature a price indicator, so you can still see when you’re getting a good deal. Our price indicator uses several data points to show you how the asking price compares to similar cars for sale on Autotrader, and help you find the right car at the right price. We keep dealer profile reviews separate (you can see those on the dealer’s profile page) so you’re getting an accurate view of the car’s value, not tempered by who’s selling it.
Choice of stock
CarGurus UK lists used and approved used cars, vans and trucks on their site.
In addition to used and approved used cars, Autotrader also stock new cars, bikes, motorhomes and caravans, trucks, and plant and farm machinery. We also offer car leasing, PCP and HP deals.
Autotrader
| Vehicles type | ||||||||
| Finance available | ||||||||
| Trade sellers | ||||||||
| Private sellers | ||||||||
CarGurus
| Vehicles type | ||||||||
| Finance available | ||||||||
| Trade sellers | ||||||||
| Private sellers | ||||||||
Valuing your car
CarGurus offers a car valuation tool that is based on their instant market value, which compares data points including make, model, trim and year to estimate a fair retail price.
Autotrader offer a free online car valuation to help buyers understand how much their car is worth.
Checking vehicle history
Both Autotrader and CarGurus offer a five-point check on all used cars advertised online.
On Autotrader, you can also buy a comprehensive 26-point independent report on the vehicle for complete peace of mind.
Saving and comparing adverts
You can save searches on both CarGurus and Autotrader.
On Autotrader, you can save and compare up to four cars without an account. If you have an Autotrader account, you can save and compare as many as you like!
Compare key features
Once you’ve saved the vehicles you like on Autotrader, you can revisit your saved preferences and easily compare their key features, including gearbox, fuel type, mileage and engine size. It also shows how different vehicles are priced. We also include additional information on the dealer’s rating and distance from your location so you can make a more informed decision on where you buy from.
Get notified when a specific car is listed
If you’re after something specific and it isn’t listed on Autotrader, you can save your search and we’ll send you a notification when a car that matches your search criteria is added. In two simple steps you can save your search – just choose the make and model you’re after and select ‘save search’. We’ll notify you as soon as a car of your liking is listed so that you never miss a good deal.
How do we compare?
How do we stack up against other automotive websites?
* Please note this is a non-exhaustive list.
You may also like:
Who are Autotrader?
Offering used cars from private sellers and trusted UK dealerships, brand new cars and more, Autotrader have over 40 years of experience as the UK’s largest automotive marketplace.
About Autotrader
We're experts on cars, with over 40 years experience in the automotive industry, so you can count on us to bring you the best deals.
Autotrader Trustpilot rating: Excellent
Score is based on 100,930 reviews