Share

The Auto Trader expert verdict: ★★★★★ ★★★★★ 3.3

Hybrid badging shouts about the revised Fiat 500’s first step into the electrically assisted age but it isn’t quite the revolution you might have hoped for. You can’t cruise around on electric power alone, the system instead offering a mild boost and measures to help you save on tax and fuel costs. Overall the 500 is showing its age somewhat but remains a stylish and distinctive choice in the city car sector, the new hybrid engine helping to keep it relevant.

Reasons to buy

  • Cute, cheeky looks
  • Retro-styled interior
  • Low running costs

Running costs for a Fiat 500 3/5

Making hybrids viable in the cost-conscious city car segment is a tough challenge for manufacturers but Fiat has successfully grasped the nettle and breathed fresh life into its long-lived 500 with an electric kick. It isn’t a full hybrid like a Prius, rather it’s small electric motor combined with a new 1.0-litre petrol for a small power boost and more sophisticated start-stop system to save fuel in city driving. It’s broadly equivalent to the outgoing 1.2 for power but Fiat claims CO2 reductions of nearly a fifth and says the small extra cost of the system will repay itself in savings on tax and petrol within the first year of ownership. The purchase price is competitive too, being a few hundred pounds more than a Toyota Aygo but comparable with a VW Up while better on fuel and emissions. Bargain hunters, meanwhile, can seek deals on the remaining stock of the outgoing 1.2 and TwinAir versions.

Reliability of a Fiat 500 3/5

Fiat currently holds a solid mid-table position in the manufacturer rankings of Warranty Direct’s Reliability Index, and as an individual model, the 500 fares pretty well, too. It’s worth noting, though, that almost half the faults reported centre around axle and suspension problems. The car comes with a three-year/unlimited mileage warranty, which is competitive by class standards, although some rivals – like the Hyundai i10 and Kia Picanto – are a lot more generous.

Safety for a Fiat 500 3/5

Standard safety kit includes front, side and curtain airbags, plus another to protect the driver’s knees. Stability control, hill start assist and tyre pressure monitoring are also standard. All but the most basic trim get fog lights and parking sensors too. But, compared with more up to date alternatives like the Hyundai i10, there’s no escaping the Fiat 500 is showing its age and it lacks the autonomous emergency braking, blind spot warnings and other active safety features buyers now take for granted.

How comfortable is the Fiat 500 2/5

True, the streets of Bologna where we tested the new 500 Hybrid are pretty terrible with big potholes and lots of cobbled sections but, from previous experience, the ride has never been a strong point on any surface. Put simply it feels crude and hard work on the urban streets it should shine on, while lacking refinement beyond city limits. It’s not helped by a driving position so high it feels like you’re sitting on a bar stool, no reach adjustment in the wheel and seat cushions too short for longer-legged drivers. The steering is also unnaturally light while the hybrid system’s regeneration means inconsistent braking that can be hard to judge. For all that it’s still a fun car to zip around in, the character counting for a lot.

Obviously, you can’t expect a city car to have tons of space but, even by the standards of its class, the 500’s cabin is pretty cramped and the lack of a five-door option is limiting. Some of the ergonomics are pretty bad too, the fact you can easily mistake the seat height adjuster for the handbrake just one example. In summary the 500 still looks chic but there’s no escaping the style comes before substance, both in the way it goes and how comfortable it is to be in.

Features of the Fiat 500 3/5

The 500 has been on sale for a long time now and Fiat is constantly tweaking the model line-up and offering new options and special editions to keep it fresh. Customisation of paint, interior trim, wheels and decals are a big part of the 500 offer too and there’s a bewildering array of choice here. One consistent theme is that the most basic model in the range really is that, but you could argue that’s true to the original 500’s minimalist roots. Realistically though you’re likely to want the air conditioning, DAB, Bluetooth, parking sensors and other modern conveniences you get as you move up the trim levels. A decent sized touchscreen is standard on all but the most basic model, some versions including navigation too but all featuring Apple CarPlay and Android Auto if you’d rather use phone-based apps instead.

Power for a Fiat 500 3/5

We were fans of the basic 1.2-litre this new hybrid model replaces and, for all the downsizing and fancy tech, the power output and performance are comparable. The five-speed gearbox on the outgoing model is now a six-speed for improved flexibility and Duologic branded automatic is still available but only with the old engine.

For all the hybrid hype the 500 is fundamentally a regular petrol-powered city car with a fancy starter motor, though the new engine is commendably smooth and what power there is can be appreciated throughout the rev range. You need to apply yourself if you’re to fully realise the benefits of the hybrid system, however, the ‘sailing’ function only working if you shift out of gear and coast up to the lights in neutral. If you do that it’ll cut the petrol engine below 20mph, only restarting it when you dip the clutch to select first and pull away. How many drivers will be bothered to go to the effort is open to question.

You may still find versions of the 500 available with the previous model year engines, these comprising the non-hybrid 1.2-litre with 69 horsepower and the 85 horsepower version of Fiat’s neat two-cylinder turbocharged TwinAir. The latter is distinctive and pulls more strongly than the 1.2 but isn’t the smoothest or most refined engine in the world. Running costs for both are pretty similar, at least by official numbers. You can get the 1.2 with the Duologic automatic gearbox too, though this isn’t the slickest system of its kind and it suffers on fuel consumption and emissions.

Meanwhile, the feisty Abarth versions remain on sale but these are best considered a standalone models aimed at a more enthusiast crowd.