Security Alert: Fraudulent text message in circulation Close

Expert review

Published: 28th November 2010 Updated: 10th November 2014

Contributors

Saab 9-5 Saloon (2010 - 2011) Expert review

Saab 9-5 saloon (2010 - 2012) expert review by Auto Trader's motoring experts, covering price, specification, running costs, practicality, safety and how it drives.

Published: 28th November 2010 Updated: 10th November 2014
View images
The Auto Trader expert verdict: 3.1 The all-new Saab 9-5 offers acres of space inside, decent equipment levels and a top-notch safety record. Running costs are competitive too, although dynamics are disappointingly below par.

Pros

  • Low CO2 and high mpg
  • Distinctive design
  • Plenty of room

Cons

  • Interior quality disappointing
  • Outclassed by rivals
  • Holds value poorly

At a glance

Contributors

Interested in buying a 9-5?

Search Used 9-5 Search New 9-5 Local 9-5 dealers

Equipment

Exterior

Interior

Performance

Practicality

Reliability

Ride and handling

Running costs

Safety

Why buy?

Exterior Our rating 3/5

The new Saab 9-5 is the first all-new Saab for quite some time and despite using a stretched Vauxhall Insignia platform, it looks like a proper Saab. It features a traditional Saab nose treatment, with chrome trim fitted around the headlamps. Flagship Aero models are fitted with deeper and sportier bumpers.

Interior Our rating 2/5

Despite being all-new, the cabin feels quite dated. The air vent design is the same one that Saab has used again and again over the past few decades. The quality of the plastics used within the cabin really aren’t up to scratch. Most buyers will expect considerably better from an executive saloon. The cabin lacks the attention to detail and tight panel gaps of its premium rivals. The bright green displays on the instrument cluster are attractive though, and lift the otherwise sombre environment.

Practicality Our rating 4/5

The 9-5 is a long car with acres of space inside. Rear seats passengers can stretch out with generous levels of legroom. However headroom is impeded by the sloping roofline. The boot is large and well shaped, and compares favourably to  rivals from Mercedes-Benz and BMW. The seats are very comfortable, and a multi-adjustable steering column helps achieve a perfect driving position.

Ride and handling Our rating 2/5

Most 9-5s will spend the majority of their time on the motorway, and that’s exactly where the Saab is best suited. Enthusiastic drivers will need to look elsewhere to satisfy their desire for top-notch handling and ride, though. The 9-5’s handling is perfectly safe, but the steering is vague and the body rolls quite a bit in corners. The ride gets unsettled all too quickly on poor roads. With considerable wind noise and a fairly noisy diesel engine, the 9-5 isn’t as refined as it should be.

Performance Our rating 4/5

All of the 9-5s five engines are turbocharged, with three petrol units and two diesels on offer. Customers can also opt for a four-wheel-drive chassis. The entry-level 1.6-litre petrol engine develops 178bhp. It can accelerate to 62mph in 9.5 seconds and reach 137mph. There’s also a 217bhp 2-litre turbo engine, and a flagship 2.8-litre V6 turbo that delivers 296bhp. It can accelerate to 62mph in 6.9 seconds and has a top speed of 155mph. The lowest-powered diesel produces 158bhp, can accelerate to 62mph in 9.9 seconds and has a top speed of 134mph. The twin-turbocharged version of the same engine delivers 187bhp. It can accelerate to 62mph in 8.8 seconds and has a maximum speed of 143mph.

Running costs Our rating 3/5

Each of the five engines delivers competitive CO2 emissions and good fuel economy. The entry-level 158bhp 2.0-litre TiD emits just 139g/km of CO2 and returns 53.2mpg average fuel economy. The 1.6-litre turbocharged petrol engine delivers 178bhp and strong pulling power. It emits 179g/km of CO2, while delivering 36.2mpg average fuel economy. Insurance costs are impressively low for all models, and Saab resale values are slowly beginning to improve.

Reliability Our rating 3/5

Saab’s reliability record hasn’t always been the best and needs to improve enormously if the company wants to compete in the premium sector. And because many of the parts are sourced from the General Motors parts bin, it is affected by similar faults to Vauxhalls. Owners are traditionally a loyal bunch, and now that the new owner, Spyker Cars, is reinvigorating the brand, this can only be good news for the future of Saab.

Safety Our rating 4/5

Saab is renowned for its focus on safety, and the new 9-5 continues that tradition. When the new car was crash tested by EuroNCAP, it achieved a five-star safety rating. All models come equipped with driver, passenger, side and head airbags, as well as a passenger deactivation switch and a reminder for both passenger and driver to put their seatbelts on. There are also three Isofix child safety seat fasteners in the rear, and a display that shows whether rear seat passengers are wearing their safety belts. Electronic stability programme and traction control are standard equipment, and there’s the added reassurance of four-wheel-drive on some models. Rather surprisingly, Saab charges extra for a centre rear headrest that is standard on every other rival and rear seat side airbags cost extra too.

Equipment Our rating 4/5

All models are well-equipped. Vector SE models feature 17-inch alloy wheels, front fog lights, front and rear parking sensors, an alarm system, rain sensor, auto-dimming rear view mirrors and Bluetooth mobile phone connectivity. Also included are cruise control, air-con, heated seats, electric windows, leather steering wheel and gearknob, half-leather seats and an MP3-compatible CD player. Sporty Aero models add electric seats, alloy pedals, leather sports seats, 19-inch alloy wheels, xenon headlights and sports bumpers. Key optional extras include sat-nav, privacy glass, a head-up display, electronically controlled suspension and a series of well-priced option packs that group popular options together to save costs.

Why buy? Our rating 2/5

The 9-5 is a distinctive-looking executive saloon that has acres of space, comfortable seats, low running costs and plenty of equipment. But you’ll need to be a serious Saab fan to overlook some of its shortfalls. Rivals like the BMW 5 Series and Mercedes-Benz E-Class offer a more convincing proposition.

Tags that apply to this car: #saab #rating #engine #seats #rear #models

Interested in buying a 9-5?

Search Used 9-5 Search New 9-5 Local 9-5 dealers

Our recommendations

Best on a budget 9-5 Vector SE 2.0 TiD Entry spec and frugal engine is best budget buy
Best seller 9-5 Vector SE 2.0 TiD Diesel engine and great specification is popular buy
Blow the budget 9-5 Aero 2.0 TTiD XWD Four-wheel-drive and diesel power is ultimate choice