Audi S4 Ten Point Test
Model tested: Audi S4 Quattro Avant S Tronic
Price as tested: £35,995 (£34,260 - £35,600)
Insurance group as tested: 18E
CO2 emissions as tested: 224g/km
CO2 emissions range: 224g/km
Company car tax %: 33%
EuroNCAP result: *****
Date tested: July 2009
Road tester: Stuart Milne
Auto Trader Ten Point Test rating: 84%
The S4 is the hottest model in the A4 range, since the demise of the white hot Audi RS4. It takes all that’s good about the standard A4 – looks, comfort, quality – and turns up the heat.
It’s not designed to rival the BMW M3 – it’s far too refined and sensible – but can it still deliver the thrills that a fast Audi promises? Stuart Milne reports.
Audi S4 gallery:
Looks | Looks Inside | Practicality | Ride and Handling | Performance
Running Costs | Reliability | Safety | Equipment | X-Factor
1. Looks
There are few saloons or estates that can turn heads like the standard Audi A4, especially when specified with the twinkling rows of LEDs in the headlamps. But the S4 is even more of a head-turner with bespoke badging, bright xenon headlamps and tasty 18-inch alloys hiding S4 logo’d painted brake callipers. The Avant models adds matt chrome roof bars.
9/10
2. Looks inside
Another elegant masterpiece from Audi. The controls are intuitively positioned, and the Multi Media Interface (MMI) control provides quick and clear access to the majority of the car’s ancillary controls. It features a sprinkling of Audi S4 logos and a set of fantastically-supportive seats, which were trimmed in high quality leather in our test car – a £970 option.
9/10
3. Practicality
With a boot measuring 480 litres, there’s plenty of space in the S4 saloon for luggage. The Avant adds just 10 more litres, as the measurements are taken to the height of the rear seats, but the latter makes it far easier to load thanks to a low boot sill and a wide opening bootlid. There’s a good amount of space in the cabin too – the wheelbase of the current model has been extended over the previous version, addressing concerns over lack of legroom.
8/10
4. Ride and Handling
Once again, Audi’s Quattro four-wheel drive system shines brightly, providing masses of grip and enough traction to get the S4’s 328bhp to the tarmac without shredding tyres. The S4 can be equipped with Audi’s clever sport differential as a cost option which when turning into a corner, will direct power to the outside rear wheel, pushing the car through the bend.
The steering is direct – and can be made more so by changing the mode on the Drive Select system – and makes it easy to place the car on the road, regardless of speed. The ride is excellent too, although there’s a bit of road noise transmitted through the low profile tyres.
10/10
The S4 is a rapid machine, reaching 62mph in 5.1 and 5.2 seconds respectively for the saloon and Avant models, although the automatic S Tronic models are around 0.2 seconds slower. Both versions are limited to 155mph, regardless of transmission.
This S4 doesn’t have the sonorous V8 unit of the previous model for a supercharged 3-litre V6, but despite losing a pair of cylinders the six offer improved performance. Pace is relentless from around 2,500rpm through to the redline, but such is the car’s refinement, it doesn’t feel enormously quick.
9/10
6. Running Costs
Thanks to the smaller capacity engine, fuel consumption and emissions are reduced over the previous model. But that doesn’t make it cheap. Audi quotes a sub-30mpg average, although hard driving will get that figure into the low teens, and CO2 emissions of 220g/km will cost a lot come tax renewal time. Insurance group 18 will be costly, as will service parts like those thin, wide tyres. Continued demand on the used market should keep used values strong, although experts say its trade value will be worth around 35 per cent of its new price after three years/36,000 miles.
6/10
Audi’s focus has been on build quality over the past few years, and they seem to be one of the best. Care may need to be taken when buying used examples given the car’s performance.
9/10
The standard A4 scored a maximum five stars in the EuroNCAP crash test programme, thanks to a full complement of airbags, ABS and stability control systems. The S4 adds better brakes and comes with the Quattro four-wheel drive system.
9/10
Like most Audis, the difference between a reasonable equipment level and a ‘fully loaded’ machine depends on your budget for options. Standard equipment isn’t huge, but includes the full bodystyling package, big alloys, four tailpipes, xenon headlights with LED daytime running lights and LED rear lights, three-zone climate control, single slot CD player and colour console screen, automatic wipers and headlights and leather/alcantara upholstery.
Full leather is a £970 option, and the Drive Select package will set you back £1,290 while the Bang & Olufsen audio system costs another £515.
7/10
10. X-Factor
Performance and comfort rarely work as well as they do in the Audi S4. Its viciously quick, but it’s possible to drive it for hours on end and still step out relaxed.
8/10
RSS